Results for redirect.test.sh

status	bash	dash	mksh	osh
pass	34	19	29	34
ok	0	10	2	1
N-I	0	7	5	0
BUG	3	1	1	0
FAIL	0	0	0	2
total	37	37	37	37

case	bash	dash	mksh	osh	description
0	pass	pass	pass	pass	>& and <& are the same
1	pass	pass	pass	pass	<&
2	pass	pass	pass	pass	2>&1 with no command
3	pass	ok	ok	pass	2&>1 (is it a redirect or is it like a&>1)
		details	details
4	pass	ok	pass	pass	Nonexistent file
		details
5	pass	pass	pass	pass	Descriptor redirect with spaces
6	pass	pass	pass	pass	Filename redirect with spaces
7	pass	pass	pass	pass	Quoted filename redirect with spaces
8	BUG	ok	pass	pass	Descriptor redirect with filename
	details	details
9	pass	pass	pass	pass	Redirect echo to stderr, and then redirect all of stdout somewhere.
10	pass	N-I	N-I	pass	Named file descriptor
		details	details
11	pass	BUG	pass	pass	Double digit fd (20> file)
		details
12	pass	pass	pass	pass	: 9> fdleak (OSH regression)
13	pass	pass	BUG	pass	: 3>&3 (OSH regression)
			details
14	pass	N-I	N-I	pass	: 3>&3-
		details	details
15	pass	pass	pass	pass	3>&- << EOF (OSH regression: fail to restore fds)
16	pass	pass	pass	pass	Open file on descriptor 3 and write to it many times
17	pass	pass	pass	pass	Open file on descriptor 4 and write to it many times
18	pass	ok	pass	pass	Redirect to empty string
		details
19	pass	ok	pass	pass	Redirect to file descriptor that's not open
		details
20	pass	pass	pass	pass	Open descriptor with exec
21	pass	pass	pass	pass	Open multiple descriptors with exec
22	pass	ok	pass	FAIL	>\| to clobber
		details		details
23	pass	N-I	pass	pass	&> redirects stdout and stderr
		details
24	pass	N-I	N-I	FAIL	>&word redirects stdout and stderr when word is not a number or -
		details	details	details
25	pass	pass	pass	pass	1>&- to close file descriptor
26	pass	N-I	N-I	pass	1>&2- to move file descriptor
		details	details
27	BUG	ok	pass	pass	1>&2- (Bash bug: fail to restore closed fd)
	details	details
28	pass	pass	pass	pass	<> for read/write
29	pass	pass	pass	pass	<> for read/write named pipes
30	pass	N-I	pass	pass	&>> appends stdout and stderr
		details
31	pass	pass	pass	pass	exec redirect then various builtins
32	BUG	pass	pass	ok	can't mention big file descriptor
	details			details
33	pass	ok	ok	pass	: >/dev/null 2> / (OSH regression: fail to pop fd frame)
		details	details
34	pass	ok	pass	pass	echo foo >&100 (OSH regression: does not fail with invalid fd 100)
		details
35	pass	ok	pass	pass	echo foo >&N where N is first unused fd
		details
36	pass	N-I	N-I	pass	exec {fd}>&- (OSH regression: fails to close fd)
		details	details

116 passed, 13 OK, 12 not implemented, 5 BUG, 2 failed, 0 timeouts, 0 cases skipped
2 failed under osh

Details on runs that didn't PASS

dash	3 2&>1 (is it a redirect or is it like a&>1) stdout: status=0 stderr: dash: 1: 2: not found
mksh	3 2&>1 (is it a redirect or is it like a&>1) stdout: status=0 stderr:
dash	4 Nonexistent file stdout: status=2 stderr: dash: 1: cannot open /home/uke/oil/_tmp/spec-tmp/redirect.test.sh.20687/04-dash/nonexistent.txt: No such file
bash	8 Descriptor redirect with filename stdout: status=0 stderr:
dash	8 Descriptor redirect with filename stdout: stderr: dash: 2: Syntax error: Bad fd number
dash	10 Named file descriptor stdout: stderr: dash: 1: exec: {myfd}: not found
mksh	10 Named file descriptor stdout: stderr: mksh: <stdin>[1]: {myfd}: not found
dash	11 Double digit fd (20> file) stdout: stderr: dash: 1: exec: 20: not found
mksh	13 : 3>&3 (OSH regression) stdout: stderr:
dash	14 : 3>&3- stdout: stderr: dash: 2: Syntax error: Bad fd number
mksh	14 : 3>&3- stdout: stderr: mksh: <stdin>[1]: 3>&3- : illegal file descriptor name
dash	18 Redirect to empty string stdout: result=2 stderr: dash: 2: cannot create : Directory nonexistent dash: 5: cannot create : Directory nonexistent
dash	19 Redirect to file descriptor that's not open stdout: stderr: dash: 8: 7: Bad file descriptor
dash	22 >\| to clobber stdout: status=2 XX ZZ stderr: dash: 5: cannot create /home/uke/oil/_tmp/spec-tmp/redirect.test.sh.20687/22-dash/c.txt: File exists
osh	22 >\| to clobber [osh stdout] Expected 'status=1\nXX\nZZ\n', got 'status=0\nYY\nZZ\n' stdout: status=0 YY ZZ stderr:
dash	23 &> redirects stdout and stderr stdout: STDOUT stderr: STDERR
dash	24 >&word redirects stdout and stderr when word is not a number or - stdout: stderr:
mksh	24 >&word redirects stdout and stderr when word is not a number or - stdout: stderr:
osh	24 >&word redirects stdout and stderr when word is not a number or - [osh stdout] Expected 'STDOUT\nSTDERR\n', got '' [osh status] Expected 0, got 2 stdout: stderr: stdout_stderr.py >&$tmp ^~~~ [ stdin ]:5: Invalid descriptor 'osh-20920.txt'. Expected D, -, or D- where D is an integer grep: osh-20920.txt: No such file or directory grep: osh-20920.txt: No such file or directory
dash	26 1>&2- to move file descriptor stdout: stderr: dash: 4: Syntax error: Bad fd number
mksh	26 1>&2- to move file descriptor stdout: stderr: mksh: <stdin>[3]: 6>&5- : illegal file descriptor name
bash	27 1>&2- (Bash bug: fail to restore closed fd) stdout: hello stderr: bash: line 19: 7: Bad file descriptor
dash	27 1>&2- (Bash bug: fail to restore closed fd) stdout: stderr: dash: 19: Syntax error: Bad fd number
dash	30 &>> appends stdout and stderr stdout: stderr:
bash	32 can't mention big file descriptor stdout: hi hi hi stderr:
osh	32 can't mention big file descriptor stdout: hi hi hi 100 stderr:
dash	33 : >/dev/null 2> / (OSH regression: fail to pop fd frame) stdout: stderr: dash: 1: cannot create /: Is a directory
mksh	33 : >/dev/null 2> / (OSH regression: fail to pop fd frame) stdout: stderr: mksh: <stdin>[1]: can't create /: Is a directory
dash	34 echo foo >&100 (OSH regression: does not fail with invalid fd 100) stdout: stderr: dash: 3: Syntax error: Bad fd number
dash	35 echo foo >&N where N is first unused fd stdout: stderr: dash: 8: Syntax error: Bad function name
dash	36 exec {fd}>&- (OSH regression: fails to close fd) stdout: stderr:
mksh	36 exec {fd}>&- (OSH regression: fails to close fd) stdout: stderr: